The Big Bad Fox

Although this concept of role reversal may be well-trod, Renner handles it deftly, making the predictable feel satisfying. A comically charming underfox tale. 

Gr 3-6--The proverbial fox may be a menace to the henhouse--but not the hero of this work. The titular character lacks gumption, guile, or cunning, and the chickens send him running each time he ventures into the farmyard. Taking pity on the fox, the wolf proposes playing the long game: stealing eggs and eventually eating the hatched chickens. The fox successfully makes off with the eggs, but things get complicated when the chicks emerge and (surprise, surprise!) assume that the fox is their mother. Though this work is similar in look and tone to typical comic strips (bulging-eyed, caricaturelike characters with exaggerated expressions; occasional slapstick violence; motion lines), there's a sophistication to the art that recalls the author/illustrator's roots as a celebrated filmmaker and cartoonist. Renner sets the individual scenes against a white backdrop, free of borders, resulting in a clean design, and the use of color, texture, and shading is top-notch. While much of the humor derives from somewhat predictable setups, such as the fox's botched attempts at proving that he can be just as intimidating as the wolf, it's sure to tickle young funny bones, and the author injects the narrative with a sly, edgy sensibility that sets this title apart from more typical fare. This one has heart, too, depicting the fox's burgeoning feelings of affection toward his unlikely ward. VERDICT Bound to keep adults and kids alike laughing, this is a winning selection for comic book fans, reluctant readers, and those who enjoy subversive comedy.--Mahnaz Dar, School Library Journal Copyright 2017 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

French graphic novelist Renner's hapless fox doesn't like to kill prey, and he's putty in the hands of the local wolf, who talks him into stealing three eggs from a farm to be eaten once they hatch. "It's simple," the wolf promises. "You just put them in your mouth and chew. I'll show you." Renner's cramped, spidery lines and diminutive vignettes convey an ever-changing kaleidoscope of expressions on the face of the fox: dismay, shock, sheepish embarrassment. Not unpredictably, the three fluffy chicks grow to love their parent ("If Mommy's the Big Bad Fox, then we're Little Bad Foxes!"), and the fox, in spite of himself, finds that he's attached to them, too. Although a couple of the episodes skew too long, Renner's tone hits the sweet spot between snarkiness and sentimentality, and Johnson's translation is seamless. The supporting characters on the farm deserve recognition, too, such as the hen who organizes her colleagues to beat the pulp out of foxes, and the lazy hound who tries replacing the stolen eggs with refrigerator equivalents. Ages 7-11. (June)

Copyright 2017 Publishers Weekly, LLC Used with permission.

Graphic novels fans from grades three and up are all going to find some- thing to like here from the art to the humor to the tender underbelly... In a celebratory era of powerful, memorable, visually significant graphic novels, this one happily joins the mountain near the top.— Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books, starred review